Finale

[dominic]

4: a well-rounded, unpredictable season with an amazing finale. Full of great characters and strategy.
3: Ellis domination because we earned it. Also lots of pre-merge strategy and great blindsides (don't smile Ellen)
1: the first of the series and it was a very entertaining game. Those who weren't here to watch wouldn't know, obviously.
5: I thought this season was interesting, but a lot of people relied on gimmicks and FvF seasons don't do much for me. Also this finale questioning is KILLING ME
2: zzzzzzzzzzzzzzz other than Henry, Annie, and Emily.

Just my opinion.

[Morgan]

AS from this season:
Ben, Thiago, Mark, Knox, Gloria (all confirmed), Liam (waiting for confirmation)

Alternates: Starr & Selena

[ellen]

Season 3 (I'm biased obviously) and Season 4 are my favorites.

I don't think that Season 3 was as predictable as it seems to have been at first glance. Ellis was a powerhouse yeah, but we were always on the verge of fracturing. It was nothing short of a miracle that we made the Final Six in tact; each round different people were on the verge of flipping for various reasons. I also think that the cast was phenomenal. We didn't have any two people alike really. Everyone fit a different role well: the sweetheart, the underdog, the crazy bitch, etcetera... and of course who could forget the classic Survivor archetype: INV late game blonde hottie.

Season 4 I like for different reasons. It was chaos and a roller coaster ride and the comeback story at the end was great. Lots of blindsides and very much a Pearl Islands type of stage in the series progression.

[Ryan]

Jun 1, 2013 21:47:54 GMT -5 Morgan said:

AS from this season:
Ben, Thiago, Mark, Knox, Gloria (all confirmed), Liam (waiting for confirmation)

Alternates: Starr & Selena

But Carly is fighting so hard for a spot in her confessional.


CARLY FAN 4EVER AND EVER <333

[ellen]

Carlfierce SALTS goddess.

[emily]

Jun 1, 2013 21:47:54 GMT -5 Morgan said:

AS from this season:
Ben, Thiago, Mark, Knox, Gloria (all confirmed), Liam (waiting for confirmation)

Alternates: Starr & Selena

Eww @ Gloria getting a fourth shot while Selena only got 2. She was a goddess queen and has the perfect story arc to get a chance to redeem herself in AS, and it would lead to a better balance of the seasons since there will be two Season 1 peeps #_# Nostalgia <#

The others aside from Gloria are very AS worthy tho IMO

[Morgan]

Liam dropped. Currently debating between Starr/Selena. I am leaning toward Selena.

[a hot fucking mess]

I want to like and dislike that post at the same time.

[emily]

Gloria is terrible.

[dominic]

SELENA

[a hot fucking mess]

I cannot even begin to stomach Gloria's retched jury statement. That was painful and I hate it. Hatehatehate.

[aj]

Is Zac's picture of him and Taylor not the cutest thing ever?

[tess]

PLease let Starr take my spot over Gloria

[tess]

Jun 1, 2013 17:49:56 GMT -5 emily said:

May 31, 2013 21:31:42 GMT -5 michael said:

My ranking of the seasons:


5 >>> 2 >>>>>>>>> 3 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 4

No?

4 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 3 > 1 > 5 > 2

IMNSHO and I'm bascially looking at the entire seasons, not just how they ended. Season 2 had the worst overall cast with the most inactives, though some of the merge was really interesting. Season 4 was crazy and amazing right off the bat and it's one of the most interesting games I've ever watched. THANKS TERESA <3

5 is only this low for me because Selena got booted too early, but other than that I enjoyed it.

NO THANKS!

For me Season 4 was amazing to play in. I felt like there were nearly no boring rounds, because something ALWAYS happened. Don't know too much bout the other seasons to judge them but I don't think it gets any better than S4


#StarrForAllStars

[Ryan]

#SelenaForAllStars